
Sophia Bennett
Crypto Analyst
TL;DR
The Supreme Court declined on Monday to hear Custodia Bank's appeal, leaving in place a Tenth Circuit ruling that regional Reserve Banks can refuse master accounts even to legally eligible banks. Custodia sought an account for six years. Crypto-focused banks now have little recourse in court when a Reserve Bank says no.
Key takeaways
- The Supreme Court denied review of Custodia's petition (docket 26-62) with a one-line order and no explanation.
- The Tenth Circuit ruled 2-1 on 31 October 2025 that Reserve Banks decide for themselves who gets a master account, even when the applicant qualifies on paper.
- The Kansas City Fed rejected Custodia's application on 27 January 2023, citing a business model focused narrowly on crypto-assets.
- Without a master account, a bank must reach Fedwire and other payment services through a correspondent institution.
- Remaining options are political or administrative: Congress could write access rules into law, or the Fed could revise its guidelines, but nobody has signaled either.
Six years. That is how long Custodia Bank pursued a single account at the Federal Reserve, and on Monday the Supreme Court ended the chase with a one‑line order. The justices declined to hear the Wyoming bank's petition in its fight with the Fed's Board of Governors, docket number 26‑62.
The order carried no explanation, and none was required. When the Court denies review, the lower court's ruling simply stays in force.
What the Court Left Standing
The ruling in question is the Tenth Circuit's 2‑1 decision of 31 October 2025. It held that regional Reserve Banks decide for themselves who gets a master account, even when the applicant qualifies on paper. Judge David Ebel wrote the opinion, and Judge Veronica Rossman joined him.
The majority's logic had two legs. Section 342 of the Federal Reserve Act says a Reserve Bank may accept deposits, which the judges read as permission rather than a duty. The Monetary Control Act of 1980 says the Fed's services shall be offered to nonmember banks as well as members. The majority took that language to govern how the services are priced, not whether a given bank can walk in the door.
Judge Timothy Tymkovich dissented. In his view, "shall means shall." When the full circuit declined to rehear the case on 13 March 2026, he compared losing an account to a death sentence for a bank. Judges Hartz and Eid voted with him to rehear.
I think that split is the most interesting part of the saga. Three appellate judges wanted a second look, and the Supreme Court still stayed out.
A Bank Told It Was Eligible
Custodia holds a Wyoming special purpose depository institution charter. It cannot make loans, and it has to keep customers' dollar deposits fully backed by liquid assets. That is about as conservative as a bank gets.
It applied to the Federal Reserve Bank of Kansas City for a master account in October 2020. According to the case record, as Bitcoin Magazine summarized it, the Kansas City Fed told the bank in January 2021 that it met the legal criteria and raised no obvious obstacles. A membership application followed in August 2021.
Then the rules moved. In August 2022 the Board of Governors issued guidelines that sorted applicants into three tiers. Institutions with no federal deposit insurance and no federal banking supervisor landed in Tier 3, which gets the toughest scrutiny. Custodia was in that group.
On 27 January 2023, the Kansas City Fed said no. It pointed to a business model focused narrowly on crypto‑assets and judged the risks highly likely to conflict with safe and sound banking. The Board rejected the membership bid the same day.
Custodia had already sued in June 2022. Judge Scott Skavdahl in Wyoming ruled against it on 29 March 2024, and the appeals followed.
Why a Master Account Matters
A master account is a bank's own account at a Federal Reserve Bank, and it is the route into Fedwire and other central bank payment services. A bank without one sends its money through a correspondent institution. That means depending on another firm's willingness to keep you as a client.
For a bank whose whole pitch is safe custody of digital‑asset customers' dollars, that is a structural handicap. Its settlement runs through someone else's plumbing.
The practical lesson is blunt. A state charter can make a bank eligible on paper and still leave it outside the Fed's payment system. For now, at least within the Tenth Circuit, crypto‑focused banks and other novel charters have little to argue in court when a Reserve Bank says no. Critics have long used the label "Operation Choke Point 2.0" for the wider pattern of crypto firms losing bank access.
The July petition came from Custodia's lawyer, Kannon Shanmugam, and asked one thing: whether presidents of regional Reserve Banks may turn away a nonmember bank that meets the legal requirements. Both the Board and the Kansas City Fed urged the justices to stay out. The Court considered the petition at its 13 November conference and denied it Monday.
The Rates and Regulation Angle
The ruling matters beyond one small bank because the master account is where the Fed's policy plumbing meets the private sector. Banks with accounts hold reserves there and settle payments directly, which ties them to the central bank's rate decisions in a way correspondent clients are not. A firm outside that system sits one step removed from monetary policy transmission.
That also shifts bargaining power. With courts out of the picture, the gatekeeping power sits with Reserve Bank officials and the Board's own guidelines, which the Fed can rewrite whenever it chooses. Whoever writes those guidelines now effectively sets the terms for crypto's access to the banking core.
What to Watch Now
Neither Custodia nor chief executive Caitlin Long had commented as of mid‑morning Monday. What they do next is anyone's guess, though the court options look exhausted.
What is left is political and administrative. Congress could write access rules into statute, or the Fed could revise its own guidelines. Nobody has signaled that either is coming. Markets did not flinch, with bitcoin at $65,047 as of 17:19 UTC, and this was never a price story.
It is a story about who decides. For crypto banks that question now has an answer, and it is a Reserve Bank official, not a judge.
