
Sophia Bennett
Crypto Analyst
TL;DR
Paul Brody, CEO of Nightfall Networks, argues enterprise blockchain deserves a second life. He says about 18 ventures failed because public-style ledgers exposed too much and private chains were slow and costly. He points to cheaper Ethereum transactions and better privacy tools, though he sells privacy infrastructure, so the claims come from an advocate.
Key takeaways
- Brody says he found 18 failed enterprise blockchain ventures, some backed by Deutsche Bank, HSBC and IBM, and does not claim the count is complete.
- He says the common flaw was that companies do not want rivals seeing orders, prices and counterparties, and public-style ledgers showed too much.
- He says Ethereum handled about 1 million transactions a day in 2020 with fees sometimes at $30 to $50, while most transactions now cost less than a penny.
- Brody sells privacy infrastructure for a living, so his case is that of an advocate.
- The test to watch is a large named company running real production volume on a public chain with privacy built in, and staying after the pilot press release fades.
Eighteen. That's how many enterprise blockchain ventures Paul Brody says he found after a quick search of the wreckage, and he doesn't claim the count is complete. Deutsche Bank, HSBC and IBM backed some of them. Almost none of it stuck.
Brody, founder and chief executive of Nightfall Networks, now argues the category deserves a second life. His case, published as an opinion piece on Cointelegraph on Nov. 15, rests on a dog food comparison. I think it's a better argument than it sounds.
Pets.com Was Early, Not Wrong
Pets.com raised $110 million, with Amazon among the investors, to sell pet supplies online. It collapsed. The lesson everyone took: nobody can profitably mail a 50‑pound bag of kibble. Then came Chewy. By Brody's account, its latest fiscal year brought roughly $12.6 billion of revenue and a profit of about $223 million.
His reading is that the idea was fine. Logistics, customer habits and unit economics hadn't caught up yet. He applies the same logic to the money the crypto industry burned on corporate chains between 2017 and 2023. He guesses the total rivals the Pets.com loss and may exceed it. It's a guess, and I'd treat it as one.
The pitch for those chains was simple. Companies still swap data across their borders through emailed spreadsheets, or through costly proprietary links that a dominant buyer forces on its suppliers. A shared ledger promised real‑time visibility without the lock‑in.
Why the Last Wave Drowned in Transparency
Brody's list of failures is long. It includes the shipping platform TradeLens, the trade‑finance network We.Trade, the insurance venture B3i, the Australian exchange's settlement overhaul known as CHESS replacement, and the diamond‑and‑art provenance firm Everledger, among others. Each had its own story. Brody says they shared one flaw. No company wants rivals watching its orders, prices and counterparties, and public‑style ledgers show too much.
The workaround was a private, permissioned chain loaded with extra machinery to hide information. Brody calls the results uniformly slow and expensive. The few survivors, he says, have "de‑chained" and gone back to ordinary software subscriptions.
The damage went past the balance sheets. Plenty of corporate users left with a one‑line conclusion: they tried blockchain and it didn't work. That belief may be the hardest thing to reverse. A failed pilot with a famous logo on it moves through a boardroom faster than any protocol upgrade.
Enterprise Blockchain Gets Cheaper Rails
Brody says the underlying machinery has changed. In 2020, Ethereum processed about 1 million transactions a day, and fees periodically jumped to between $30 and $50 when demand surged. Today, he says, most transactions cost less than a penny, and capacity is heading toward billions a day. In his telling, the old scaling trilemma is no longer a live debate.
His subhead also points to better privacy tools and deeper onchain liquidity. I can't tell you how those claims hold up in detail. It's an advocate's case, and he sells privacy infrastructure for a living. Read it with that in mind.
Still, privacy is the point that matters. Cheap blockspace alone wouldn't have saved TradeLens. A bank or a shipper needs to prove a transaction happened without showing a competitor the terms. If that can now be done on a public network without contortions, the economics look different from the 2018 consortium model.
The market backdrop isn't friendly. On the day Brody's piece ran, Ether was trading near $1,815 and Bitcoin near $64,800, according to the price ticker on the page. Nobody should expect treasury departments to pile into onchain workflows on the back of a bull run, and there isn't one. Any revival would come from procurement and finance teams that care about reconciliation costs, not token charts.
Brody's analogy also skips a harder question. Chewy won because customers wanted the product and warehouses got smarter. Who is the customer here? Corporate buyers burned once are slow to try again, and regulators in banking and trade finance move slower still.
So the test is plain. I'd watch for a named company, ideally a large one, putting real production volume through a public chain with privacy built in, and staying there after the pilot press release fades. One of those would tell us more than another consortium announcement ever could.
